Enrollee Mix, Treatment Intensity, and Cost in Competing Indemnity and HMO Plans

Daniel Altman, David M. Cutler, Richard Zeckhauser

NBER Working Paper No. 7832
Issued in August 2000
NBER Program(s):Health Care

We examine why managed care plans are less expensive than traditional indemnity insurance plans. Our database consists of the insurance experiences of over 200,000 state and local employees in Massachusetts and their families, who are insured in a single pool. Within this group, average HMO costs are 40 percent below those of the indemnity plan. We evaluate cost differences for 8 conditions representing over 10 percent of total health expenditures. They are: heart attacks, cancers (breast, cervical, colon, prostate), diabetes (type I and II), and live births. For each condition, we identify the portions of the cost differential arising from differences in treatment intensity, enrollee mix, and prices paid for the same treatment. Surprisingly, treatment intensity differs hardly at all between the HMOs and the indemnity plan. That is, relative to their fee-for-service competitor, HMOs do not curb the use of expensive treatments. Across the 8 conditions, roughly half of the HMO cost savings is due to the lower incidence of the diseases in the HMOs. Virtually all of the remaining savings come because HMOs pay lower prices for the same treatment.

download in pdf format
   (228 K)

email paper

A non-technical summary of this paper is available in the November 2000 NBER Digest.  You can sign up to receive the NBER Digest by email.

Machine-readable bibliographic record - MARC, RIS, BibTeX

Document Object Identifier (DOI): 10.3386/w7832

Published: Altman, Daniel & Cutler, David & Zeckhauser, Richard, 2003. "Enrollee mix, treatment intensity, and cost in competing indemnity and HMO plans," Journal of Health Economics, Elsevier, vol. 22(1), pages 23-45, January. citation courtesy of

Users who downloaded this paper also downloaded* these:
Cutler and Zeckhauser Adverse Selection in Health Insurance
Cutler, Lincoln, and Zeckhauser w15164 Selection Stories: Understanding Movement Across Health Plans
Stabile and Thomson w19439 The Changing Role of Government in Financing Health Care: An International Perspective
Cutler and Zeckhauser w7176 The Anatomy of Health Insurance
Barro and Chu w8899 HMO Penetration, Ownership Status, and the Rise of Hospital Advertising
NBER Videos

National Bureau of Economic Research, 1050 Massachusetts Ave., Cambridge, MA 02138; 617-868-3900; email:

Contact Us