Premium Levels and Demand Response in Health Insurance: Relative Thinking and Zero-Price Effects

Rudy Douven, Ron van der Heijden, Thomas McGuire, Frederik T. Schut

NBER Working Paper No. 23846
Issued in September 2017, Revised in May 2018
NBER Program(s):Health Care, Health Economics

In health care systems with a competitive health insurance market, governments or other sponsors (e.g. employers) often subsidize premiums to encourage enrolment. These subsidies are typically independent of plan choice leaving the absolute premium differences in place so as not to distort consumer choice of plan. Such subsidies do, however, change the relative premium differences across plans, which, according to theories from behavioral economics, can affect choice. Consumers might be sensitive to differences relative to a reference premium (“relative thinking”). Furthermore, consumers might be particularly sensitive to a reference premium of zero (“zero-price effect”), a relevant range for some subsidized health insurance markets. This paper tests these ideas with two sources of evidence. We argue that observed equilibria in Germany and the U.S. Medicare Advantage markets are consistent with a powerful zero-price effect, resulting in an equilibrium focal pricing at zero. This contrasts with the Netherlands where equilibrium premiums are well above zero. In an empirical test using hypothetical questions in a web-based survey in these three countries, we also find evidence for both a relative thinking and a zero-price effect in the demand for health insurance. Our findings imply that well-designed subsidies can leverage relative thinking to increase demand elasticity for health plans. Creation of a powerful reference price (e.g., at zero), however, risks subverting price competition.

download in pdf format
   (656 K)

email paper

Machine-readable bibliographic record - MARC, RIS, BibTeX

Document Object Identifier (DOI): 10.3386/w23846

Published: Rudy Douven & Ron van der Heijden & Thomas McGuire & Frederik Schut, 2019. "Premium levels and demand response in health insurance: relative thinking and zero-price effects," Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, .

Users who downloaded this paper also downloaded* these:
Geruso and Layton w23876 Selection in Health Insurance Markets and Its Policy Remedies
East, Miller, Page, and Wherry w23810 Multi-generational Impacts of Childhood Access to the Safety Net: Early Life Exposure to Medicaid and the Next Generation’s Health
Poterba, Venti, and Wise w23839 Longitudinal Determinants of End-of-Life Wealth Inequality
Rau, Sarzosa, and Urzúa w23911 The Children of the Missed Pill
Maclean, Ghimire, and Nicholas w23862 Marijuana legalization and disability claiming
NBER Videos

National Bureau of Economic Research, 1050 Massachusetts Ave., Cambridge, MA 02138; 617-868-3900; email:

Contact Us