Vaccine Approvals and Mandates Under Uncertainty: Some Simple Analytics

Charles F. Manski

NBER Working Paper No. 20432
Issued in August 2014
NBER Program(s):Health Care, Health Economics, Public Economics, Economics of Aging

Social interactions make communicable disease a core concern of public health policy. A prevalent problem is scarcity of empirical evidence that are informative about how interventions affect population behavior and illness. Randomized trials, which have been important to evaluation of treatments for non-infectious diseases, are less informative about treatment of communicable diseases because they do not shed light on population-wide disease transmission. In particular, trials do not reveal the indirect preventive (herd immunity) effect of vaccination on persons who are not vaccinated or who are unsuccessfully vaccinated. This paper studies the decision problems faced by health planners who must choose whether to approve a new vaccine or mandate an approved one, but who do not know the indirect effect of vaccination. I study vaccine approval as a choice between a zero vaccination rate (rejection of the new vaccine) and whatever vaccination rate the health-care system will yield if the vaccine is approved. I study the decision to mandate an approved vaccine as a choice between vaccinating the entire population (the mandate) and the vaccination rate that would be generated by decentralized health-care decisions. Considering decision making with partial knowledge, I show that it may be possible to determine optimal policies in some cases where the planner can only bound the indirect effect of vaccination. Considering settings where optimal policy is indeterminate, I pose several criteria for decision making--expected utility, minimax, and minimax-regret--and derive the policies they yield.

download in pdf format
   (183 K)

email paper

Machine-readable bibliographic record - MARC, RIS, BibTeX

Document Object Identifier (DOI): 10.3386/w20432

Users who downloaded this paper also downloaded* these:
Bodine-Baron, Nowak, Varadavas, and Sood w19528 Conforming and Non-conforming Peer Effects in Vaccination Decisions
Danzon and Pereira w17205 Vaccine Supply: Effects Of Regulation And Competition
Wernerfelt, Slusky, and Zeckhauser w20599 Second Trimester Sunlight and Asthma: Evidence from Two Independent Studies
Danzon, Nicholson, and Pereira w9615 Productivity in Pharmaceutical Biotechnology R&D: The Role of Experience and Alliances
Currie and Rajani w20400 Within-Mother Estimates of the Effects of WIC on Birth Outcomes in New York City
NBER Videos

National Bureau of Economic Research, 1050 Massachusetts Ave., Cambridge, MA 02138; 617-868-3900; email:

Contact Us