Immigration: America's nineteenth century "law and order problem"?

Howard Bodenhorn, Carolyn M. Moehling, Anne Morrison Piehl

NBER Working Paper No. 16266
Issued in August 2010
NBER Program(s):Development of the American Economy, Law and Economics, Labor Studies

Past studies of the empirical relationship between immigration and crime during the first major wave of immigration have focused on violent crime in cities and have relied on data with serious limitations regarding nativity information. We analyze administrative data from Pennsylvania prisons, with high quality information on nativity and demographic characteristics. The latter allow us to construct incarceration rates for detailed population groups using U.S. Census data. The raw gap in incarceration rates for the foreign and native born is large, in accord with the extremely high concern at the time about immigrant criminality. But adjusting for age and gender greatly narrows that observed gap. Particularly striking are the urban/rural differences. Immigrants were concentrated in large cities where reported crime rates were higher. However, within rural counties, the foreign born had much higher incarceration rates than the native born. The interaction of nativity with urban residence explains much of the observed aggregate differentials in incarceration rates. Finally, we find that the foreign born, especially the Irish, consistently have higher incarceration rates for violent crimes, but from 1850 to 1860 the natives largely closed the gap with the foreign born for property offenses.

download in pdf format
   (306 K)

email paper

Machine-readable bibliographic record - MARC, RIS, BibTeX

Document Object Identifier (DOI): 10.3386/w16266

Published: Imm igrati on: America’s Nineteent h-Century Law and O rder Problem.” In Migration and C ulture , 295-323. Front iers of E conomics of Glo abl izati on Series. E dited by Gi l S. E pstein a nd Ira Gang. Emerald Publ ishers (2010).

Users who downloaded this paper also downloaded* these:
Butcher and Piehl w13229 Why are Immigrants' Incarceration Rates so Low? Evidence on Selective Immigration, Deterrence, and Deportation
Moehling and Piehl w13576 Immigration and Crime in Early 20th Century America
Borjas w12088 Making it in America: Social Mobility in the Immigrant Population
Bodenhorn, Moehling, and Price w15945 Short Criminals: Stature and Crime in Early America
Butcher and Piehl w6067 Recent Immigrants: Unexpected Implications for Crime and Incarceration
NBER Videos

National Bureau of Economic Research, 1050 Massachusetts Ave., Cambridge, MA 02138; 617-868-3900; email:

Contact Us