Taxes and Trading versus Intensity Standards: Second-Best Environmental Policies with Incomplete Regulation (Leakage) or Market Power

Stephen P. Holland

NBER Working Paper No. 15262
Issued in August 2009
NBER Program(s):Environment and Energy Economics, Public Economics

This paper investigates whether an emissions tax (equivalent to an emissions cap) maximizes social welfare (defined as the sum of consumer and producer surplus) in the presence of incomplete regulation (leakage) or market power by analyzing an intensity standard regulating emissions per unit of output. With no other market failures, an intensity standard indeed yields lower welfare, although combining it with a consumption tax eliminates this discrepancy. For incomplete regulation, I show that under certain conditions an intensity standard can yield higher welfare than any emissions tax (including the optimal emissions tax). This result persists even with the addition of a consumption tax, which ameliorates output distortions and can sometimes help the intensity standard attain the first best (when an emissions tax/consumption tax combination cannot). Comparing intensity standards to output-based updating shows that the latter yields higher welfare because of its additional flexibility. Finally, I show that with market power an intensity standard can yield higher welfare than the optimal emissions tax.

The intuition of these results is relatively straightforward. The weakness of an intensity standard is that it relies more on substitution effects than output effects to reduce emissions. With incomplete regulation or market power, this disadvantage may be helpful since leakage may offset gains from reducing output and since market power already inefficiently reduces output.

download in pdf format
   (316 K)

email paper

Machine-readable bibliographic record - MARC, RIS, BibTeX

Document Object Identifier (DOI): 10.3386/w15262

Published: “Taxes and Trading versus Intensity Standards: Second - Best Environmental Policies with Incomplete Regulation (Leakage) or Market Power” Journal of Environmental Economics and Management (2012) 63 (3): 375 – 387 .

Users who downloaded this paper also downloaded* these:
Fowlie w14421 Incomplete Environmental Regulation, Imperfect Competition, and Emissions Leakage
Holland, Knittel, and Hughes w13266 Greenhouse Gas Reductions under Low Carbon Fuel Standards?
Mansur w13510 Prices vs. Quantities: Environmental Regulation and Imperfect Competition
Fullerton, Leicester, and Smith w14197 Environmental Taxes
Bovenberg and Goulder w8458 Environmental Taxation and Regulation
NBER Videos

National Bureau of Economic Research, 1050 Massachusetts Ave., Cambridge, MA 02138; 617-868-3900; email:

Contact Us