Is Money Overrated? Misperceived Satisfaction from Income
People often make important choices in pursuit of higher income, but do they place too much weight on income when deciding what path to take? We test the hypothesis that individuals overestimate the marginal satisfaction from income—the expected effect of an income increase on overall life satisfaction—and therefore give income too much importance in their decisions. We designed a pre-registered experiment that elicits beliefs about the marginal satisfaction from income and randomly assigns respondents to receive scientific evidence about it. Respondents report beliefs about the marginal satisfaction from income that are substantially above the scientific benchmark, both for themselves and for others, with a larger gap for themselves. These gaps shrink when respondents are exposed to scientific evidence, and the effects persist one month later. To study whether these beliefs shape decisions, we examine how respondents weigh higher income against other considerations, such as having to work longer hours. We measure these trade-offs using personalized job-choice scenarios and a real-world decision each respondent is facing. To elicit the latter, we make a methodological contribution: an AI-led interview method that moves beyond static, predefined survey instruments by combining the flexibility of qualitative interviewing with the discipline of closed-ended survey measurement. We find that these beliefs are consequential: after learning that income matters less for life satisfaction than they initially thought, respondents place less weight on income in their decisions.
-
-
Copy CitationRafael Macedo-Rubião and Ricardo Perez-Truglia, "Is Money Overrated? Misperceived Satisfaction from Income," NBER Working Paper 35423 (2026), https://doi.org/10.3386/w35423.Download Citation
-
-