Is Taxing the Externality Enough?
A central prescription in public economics is to correct externalities by taxing the externality-generating attribute: for example, ethanol content for alcohol, THC for cannabis, sugar for sweetened beverages, or CO2 emissions for vehicles. This prescription presumes that every externality-generating product can be taxed on its own damage. When some substitutes are untaxed or taxed on a coarser base, as in every market we examine, the marginal external damage from a product depends not only on its externality content, but also on the external damage generated by the substitutes its buyers move to. We illustrate the conditions under which a simple attribute-based tax is likely to be sufficient and characterize when it fails. We then present case studies for distilled spirits and automobiles that quantify the welfare cost of ignoring within-market substitution.
-
Copy CitationChristopher Conlon and Nirupama L. Rao, Tax Policy and the Economy, Volume 41 (University of Chicago Press, 2026), chap. 1, https://www.nber.org/index%2ephp/books-and-chapters/tax-policy-and-economy-volume-41/taxing-externality-enough.Download Citation