A Citation-Based Test for Discrimination at Economics and Finance Journals

Scott Smart, Joel Waldfogel

NBER Working Paper No. 5460
Issued in February 1996

Discrimination is notoriously difficult to document. Convincing tests for discrimination require good measures of the legitimate determinants of the outcome of interest, for example wages and productivity. While few contexts provide data adequate to the task of measuring discrimination, copious bibliographic data on the impact of academic research make possible tests of discrimination in the editorial process. This study develops a test for possible bias þ with respect to author gender, prestige of author's institution, article content (theory vs. empiricism), and whether the author has ties to the editor þ using a new approach based on an analysis of citations. We treat citations as a measure of article quality and ask whether papers by certain groups receive systematically different numbers of citations. The key to our approach is the observation that editors do not simply accept or reject papers. For accepted papers, editors determine articles' order within journal issue and length based on their quality assessments. We show that these 'editorial treatment' decisions are highly correlated with citations. Thus, we infer bias against a particular group of authors if their published articles have more citations, conditional editorial treatment, than other articles. Surprisingly, we document systematic editorial bias in favor of authors located outside of top institutions.

download in pdf format
   (810 K)

email paper

Machine-readable bibliographic record - MARC, RIS, BibTeX

Document Object Identifier (DOI): 10.3386/w5460

Users who downloaded this paper also downloaded these:
Desai, Foley, and Hines w8698 Dividend Policy inside the Firm
Cherkashin, Demidova, Imai, and Krishna w13957 The Inside Scoop: Acceptance and Rejection at the Journal of International Economics
Bjorklund and Freeman w4945 Generating Equality and Eliminating Poverty, The Swedish Way
Bekaert w4818 The Time Variation of Risk and Return in Foreign Exchange Markets: A General Equilibrium Perspective
White w6063 The Legacy of Deposit Insurance: The Growth, Spread, and Cost of Insuring Financial Intermediaries
NBER Videos

National Bureau of Economic Research, 1050 Massachusetts Ave., Cambridge, MA 02138; 617-868-3900; email:

Contact Us