The Flexible Exchange Rate System: Experience and Alternatives

   (580 K)

We review ten aspects of how floating exchange rates have worked in practice, contrasted with ten characteristics that the system was supposed to have in theory. We conclude that the foreign exchange market is characterized by high transactions-volume, short-term horizons, and an absence of stabilizing speculation. As a result, the exchange rate at times strays from the equilibrium level dictated by fundamentals, contrary to theory. We then look at ten proposed alternatives to the current system. Four entail decentralized policy rules: new classical macroeconomics, a gold standard, monetarism, and nominal income targeting. Four foresee enhanced international coordination: G-7 "objective indicators," Williamson target zones, McKinnon "world monetarism," and a "Hosomi Fund." Two propose enhanced independence: a "Tobin tax" on transactions, and a dual exchange rate. We conclude that one might build a case for intervention from the observed failure of international financial markets to behave as in the theoretical ideal, but that government intervention in practice is just as likely to fall short of the theoretical ideal

Published:

• International Finance and Trade in a Polycentric World, edited by Silvio Borner, pp. 151-197. London: Macmillan Press, 1988. Reprinted in On Exchange Rates, J. Frankel, MIT Press, Cambridge, 1993 ,
• First half reprinted as Flexible Exchange rates: Experience Vs. Theory. Journal of Portfolio Management, Vol. 15, No. 2, pp. 45-54, Winter 1989.

This paper is available as PDF (580 K) or via email.

Machine-readable bibliographic record - MARC, RIS, BibTeX